With Misleading Report On ACORN, CNN Misses The Real Story In Lake Co.

CNN's Drew Griffin took his network's Special Investigations Unit to Lake County, IN yesterday in an attempt to document election problems in the area. Did he discuss the active and legitimate voter suppression campaign taking place there, in which local Republicans are blocking early voting in three Democratic leaning cities? Not at all. Instead, he focused on faulty registration cards submitted by the current bete noir of the conservative movement, the community organizing group ACORN. What's worse, his report (and most other media accounts) grossly misrepresented the intent and professionalism of ACORN's registration efforts. Watch it:

In the report, Ruthann Hoagland, a Republican member of the Lake Co. Board of Elections, tells Griffin that ACORN submitted 5,000 new registrations in the past two weeks. But during the verification process, employees found that about half were fraudulent, including multiple forms turned in with the same handwriting, one signed "Johns, Jimmy" using the address of a Jimmy John's sandwich shop in Crown Point, and others with the name of registrants that are now dead. Nationwide, registrar's offices have come across similar problems in recent days.

What Griffin fails to note, however, is that ACORN made very clear that some registrations they gathered from canvassers in Lake County may have been faulty. An ACORN spokesmen explained this in an October 7 press release:

ACORN flags and turns in three kinds of cards, those that it can verify, those that are incomplete, and those that it flags as problematic. It turns those in labeled in a special way and are very conservative in terms of what it flags as problematic. It has stacks of problematic cover sheets. [...]

The Lake County Board knew about the questionable registrations today because ACORN flagged them for the board. For example, the Jimmy John’s card is one that a caller had flagged and labeled as problematic. ACORN can get that caller to talk to the press.

According to Regina Harris, the Director of Registrations for Lake County, this claim checks out. "It's certainly true. They did have three batches separated." she told me this morning. "There was a pile they knew were good, there was some they said had missing info -- like no voter ID number or a missing birthday -- and another batch they called 'suspicious.' "

Why would ACORN submit registration forms it had deemed "suspicious"?  Because under most state laws, voter registration organizations are required to turn in all the forms they receive.  In a phone conversation today, ACORN press coordinator Charles Jackson confirmed that this is the case in Indiana.

So what explains all the faulty registration forms?  There are two probable causes. One is that some registration forms can contain simple errors. That means the registrant didn't intend to subvert the election process, but rather just made an honest mistake.

The other scenario involves the canvassers themselves. If employees want to boost their performance in the eyes of their boss or simply don't want to do the work of finding legitimate new voters, they could turn in forged or faulty registration forms.*  This is illegal and can wreak havoc on registrar's offices, but there's no evidence these imaginary people turn around and vote in November. Given Indiana's strict voter ID law, it would actually be next to impossible for anyone to cast a ballot under the name of a submarine sandwich chain or a dead person.

But these facts haven't stopped conservative critics and some in the media from incorrectly implying that ACORN's faulty registrations prove the organization is trying to forge votes and steal the election in November. An editorial in the Investor's Business Daily said, "[John] McCain would be wise to start preparing a challenge to voter registration rolls should he lose the race in a close contest." CNN even set up Griffin's segment with a graphic that read “Voter Fraud?"

What dynamic is at play here? It's the conflation of voter registration fraud -- the more common problem outlined above --  and "voter fraud," the unproven fetish of Karl Rove and his conservative cronies. By spending their energy and resources vilifying ACORN without providing the proper context, CNN and others are ignoring an actual threat to fair elections: systemic, illegal voter disenfranchisement.

*CORRECTION:  This post originally stated that many ACORN canvassers are paid by a quota system.  That is inaccurate.  All ACORN canvassers are, in fact, paid by the hour.

Comments

So voter registration fraud is OK, because it hasn't been converted into vote fraud yet?

This looks a lot more like lazy employees scamming their employer than a nefarious attempt to perpetrate fraud. Let's be honest, chances are these canvassers aren't the cream of the worker crop, so stuff like this will happen. But it should be thoroughly investigated, as should GOP "caging" and any outstanding electronic voting issues. At the 11th hour, the ailing McCain campaign and Fox News are looking for any villain that might gain some traction. I highly doubt these folks are going to contribute much to falsified votes, but again, let's be vigilant.

WONDER WHY THE WHOLE QUESTON OF ACORN AND VOTER FRAUD IS ON THE TOP OF THE AGENDA.? YES, IT IS ELECTION TIME AND BY RAISING QUESTIONS IN THE PUBLICS' MIND ABOUT FRAUD IN VOTING THE PUBLIC IS MORE LIKELY TO SUPPORT THE IDEA THAT AN ELECTION IS "STOLEN." THEY WILL BE MORE LIKELY TO SUPPORT CAGING, STRINGENT REGISTRATION AND IDENTIFICATION LAWS ETC. IN ORDER TO AVOID THE POSSIBILITY OF FRAUD.

REMEMBER THE POLITICAL MOTIVATION BEHIND THE FIREING OF US ATTORNEYS BY THE JUSTICE DEPARTMENT. THOSE FIRED DID NOT FIND A COMPELLING ARGUMENT TO PURSUE VOTER FRAUD IN INSTANCES WHERE THE REPUBLICAN OPERATIVES FELT IT WOULD BE POLITICALLY USEFUL TO DO SO. ACTUAL FACTUAL ANALYSIS FIND VOTER FRAUD IS STATISTICALLY INSIGNIFICANT iT WON'T EFFECT AN ELECTION WHAT HAS BEEN SHOWN TO EFFECT AN ELECTION IS INCOMPETENTCE OR MALICIOUS INTENT(E.G. INSUFFICIENT VOTING MACHINES, NO BACK UP PAPRE BALLOTS), PROBLEMS WITH VOTING EQUIPMENT (TAMPERING OR OTHERWISE), VOTER SUPRESSION, POLITICALLY MOTIVATED ELECTION OFFICIALS, ETC. ETC.

I wrote that voter registration fraud is "iis illegal and can wreak havoc on registrar's offices." Clearly, it's a problem. But the representations of it have been highly misleading, and the fall out from that misrepresentation can be severe.

The greatest danger of voter fraud in the coming elections will be hacking of the touch screen voting machines. Even those states which have a paper trail that supposedly can verify questionable precincts are at risk. My knowledge comes from personal experience in two elections and in trying to make the system more secure. What may look good on paper may have serious flaws in execution. I have found that neither party wants a secure system. In my opinion, the election will be won by the party with the best hackers.

Over the weekend my son of sixteen came home and told me he was register to vote. I told him that impossible it's not legal. He was some how register to vote while he was at the Mall. He told them he was underage and they didn't care said it was alright. I went to the mall and guess what it was ACORN doing this. So don't tell me there not doing anything wrong. I experienced it. I was there

You should turn in whoever said it was okay for a16 year to register to vote, to ACORN (and authorities if you wish).

ACORN has turned in a number of rogue employees who have done something like you describe. They have been at the forefront of routing out the very fraud you describe.

BTW, your son did not, and would not, be able to vote, because -- by federal law -- he'd have to show ID when he went to vote the first time (if he hadn't registered in person). So there is, again, no VOTER FRAUD here, or anywhere with those ACORN registrations!

If the Obama camp is so upset about this, maybe they should TAKE BACK THE $800,000 THEY GAVE TO THEM!

If Obama wins it's because ACORN is registering dead people and 7 year olds to vote for Obama- by way of his $800,000.

Did you also know that there are 2 DA's in Kansas City who were told to prosecute anyone who says anything that could be thought as false about Obama? This is where it starts and then Obama will be hiring the thought police so if you even look like you're thinking negatively about Obama you will be killed. This is how the Gestapo started- and it's how America will be if Obama wins. Hello North Korea!!!!!

No, I didn't know that, and I'm not sure I know it even now.

Did you know John McCain is a space alien and Sarah Palin sacrifices children to a giant brass statue?

My information is not factual, and yours may not be factual, either.

You are crazy gestapo get real you trying to scare people you must have been listning to SEAN HANNITY

Anonymous 10/10/2008 13:01, did you even read this article? He said "Many are paid by a quota system, meaning they have to submit a certain number of forms every day. If a canvasser trying to hit their numbers -- with ACORN (*or any other group for that matter), most are low-income individuals -- thinks he or she is going to fall short and could potentially lose the job, one might turn in faulty forms in hopes they will slip by. This is illegal and can wreak havoc on registrar's offices, but there's no evidence these imaginary people turn around and vote in November".

He didn't deny at ALL that in a very few cases, an extremely small percentage of canvassers may be submitting invalid registrations. This should NOT be ANY indication of ACORN as a whole and how they operate. If a few people (from ANY group) decide to shirk their responsibilities and submit suspicious or fraudulent registrations, that isn’t ACORN’s fault. ACORN fires these people and flags these suspicious registrations as possibly problematic. However, they are still required by most State laws to turn them in anyway. Why else do you think that EVERY single one of the registrations in that pile were fraudulent? ACORN had already sorted through them and weeded out those “suspicious” registrations and had marked them as such.

Obama is now saying that he didn't really have that much to do with Acorn. Is there enough room under the bus for Acorn in addtion to his racist grandmother, Rev. Wright, Bill Ayers, his chair of VP search committee (ex Fannie Mae CEO), two successive Muslim outreach chairs, .......

Don't forget to come back and Let us know what happens when your 16 year son or Mickey Mouse shows up at the polling place and tries to vote.

Mickey Mouse and a 16 year old don't have to present ID if they use an absentee ballot.

ABSENTEE BALLOTS ARE VERIFIED BY THE SUPERVISOR OF ELECTIONS OFFICE. THEY ARE REVIEWED AND CHECKED AGAINST VARIOUS LISTS (DEPENDING ON THE STATE) SUCH AS MOTOR VEHICLE LISTS, SOCIAL SECURITY LISTS,

The original article says: "Many are paid by a quota system, meaning they have to submit a certain number of forms every day."

However, I believe that's incorrect. The ACORN workers are paid by the hour, not by the registration.

Beyond that, of course, thanks for the good work in telling the TRUTH about the GOP's ACORN "voter fraud" scam!!

That's true, Brad.  All ACORN workers are paid by the hour -- not by the card.  The post has been corrected.

After reading the whole story - I see the GOP farce.
-----------------------------
Why would America REWARD complete Republican failure ?

We wont.

Obama is not responsible for Acorn...its conceivable that his campaign donated to Acorn to encourage voter registration...period. He was 8 yrs old when Ayers committed his acts...he is not responsible for Ayers...period. If you are not a Black American, you can not understand that ongoing pains of Black America which Rev. Wright expressed...but can you understand that Sarah Palin endorses the independence party in Alaska who wants to be a separate and independent nation from America and denounces America in the worst written word possible (see adn.com). Sarah Palin is a republican and Todd Palin is not a republican...he follows the independence party of Alaska...who have expressed hatred for America....period.

John Mccain, Sarah Palin, and Cindy Mccain have recently campaigned against Obama where as hatred, slander, and violence has been incited in American. They are referring to Obama as a traitor, arab, someone not like us (white), someone to kill, just plain hate-mongers...period. John Mccain (one of the Keating 5) aided the fall of the saving and loans (which cause the loss of farms) while Cindy Mccain invested with the saving and loan embezzlers (John Mccain admitting being aware of this financial gain for his family)....outrageous, period.

Sarah Palin and Todd Palin used her elected office in an attempt to have her ex-brother-in-law fired...resulting in Walt Monegan losing his job. In 2005 an Alaskan judge ordered the Palin's to back off of their obsession to destroy Wooten (the ex-brother-in-law)....misuse of office....period. The 230 million dollars in earmarks for the bridge to nowhere records of how the money was spent have alledgedly disappeared....Sarah Palin's friend was assigned to govern the dispensing of these funds?...hummmm. no need to ponder this one...period.

Sarah Palin has had three interviews which clearly depict her inability to mentally express an intelligent thought....fact...period. One can go on and on with shady dealings of the Mccain/Palin creditability....period. Q: When did politicians gain the reputation of being honest...period.

Until we get past the "thieves we like" vs. "thieves we don't like" America is screwed.

THE BOLD FACED LIES from everywhere and everyone is reaching epic and historic proportions. Electronic voting is as stupid as issuing home loans to people without verifying social security numbers.

Again this election comes down to the devil I know versus the devil I don't know. And when has anything good come from the political hotbed in Chicago.

We need to PURGE CONGRESS - NOT ENABLE THEM.

"That's not the Acorn I know."

"Actually, now that I think about it, I don't even know them"

"Anybody who says I know Acorn, even if they quote my own speeches to prove it, is swift-boating me, and that means they are really hurting you. Frankly, felons registering fake voters is just not an issue -- the issue is convincing you that George Bush is on the ballot, and anybody who says he isn't is lying and smearing and you won't stand for it."

"Fight the smears, they're all lies, I never met Acorn, Ayres, Reverend Wright, Rezko, corrupt Chicago politicians, any of them. They just passed me in the neighborhood and I didn't even wave back to them. The American people don't want to focus on the politics of personal destruction, they won't stand for it. They won't stand for any inquiry into my judgment or belief system whatsoever. They can't afford 8 more years of George W. Bush, who is single handedly responsible for everything that has gone wrong in this country. I mean, a little puppy got hit by a car the other day in my neighborhood, because there wasn't a stop sign there. And if George W. Bush and John McCain hadn't been distracted by the war in Iraq, they would have put up that stop sign, and fluffy would be alive today. What was your question about again?"

Maybe the following were missed when folks read about ACORN
1. They are the middle man in passing voter REGISTRATION forms to the Supervisor of Elections
2 They are required by law to pass on any and all voter registration forms - they do not decide if a form is correct, complete, legitimate etc. etc. We don't want them to. We want elections employees to do that.
3 The voter Registration form is not a Vote. Applying to register to vote only results in an actual vote being cast IF the registration form is processed and veted by the election employees resulting in thei registrant becoming part of the official voter list. You know the list those little old ladies and men refer to when you go in to vote and give them your ID.
4. In order to vote you must provide identification. - in this instance the State requires photo id.
5. REGISTRATION FRAUD does not necessarily result in VOTER FRAUD. VOTER FRAUD REQUIRES A VOTE.
6. If ACORN employees did not do their job -, "riped off their employer" - they should definitely be held responsible. An employer who has one of his employees steal from them should not be punished for the employee's crime. They SHOULD, in good business practice, do all they can to deter this from happening. In the case of Registrations - it is also a responsibility of the employer to do so.

The best thing the clerks office in Indiana could do, would be to allow the courthouses (the 3 satellite locations) to help process the registrations. Do they not trust their own courthouses, or is it simply easier for the GOP to have their hand in those files if they are in one place? It makes more sense to allow the locations than it does to refuse them. In Indiana you are required to show picture ID making it near impossible for fraudulent voting to take place. One reason there may be some duplicate, is that there have been numerous registration drives in the state to re-register voters whose names were purged from the list because they have not voted since before the 2006 election. If a voter checked to see if they were registered at www.indianavoters.com, and found they were not shown as being registered, they may have filled out another form, not knowing there have been delays in the clerks office getting those registrations in the database. When entering the registrations, they can simply toss duplicate registrations, or is that too difficult a task for them? It's not like those people would actually be able to vote twice, unless of course, they are republicans. Living in Lake County Indiana, I have always known that Indiana was notorious for doing everything it can to keep us from voting, it is common knowledge, not paranoia. The GOP not only fears losing the presidential election, but if we here in Lake County vote straight Democratic ticket, then Bush's buddy Mitch Daniels will be out of a job.

Let the GOP have their way, it will do them no good. We have been prepared for this. Since the start of early voting, we have been driving any voter who needs a ride, to Crown Point to vote. We are a small army and we have the resources, and the days until November 4th, to make sure each and every one of them makes their way to Crown Point to vote.

And, John McCain thought volunteers couldn't make a difference - lol.

The problem with Voter Registration Fraud, is it appears that more people are registering for a particular candidate - this drives the psychology of the race so that people will think a particular candidate is popular, is going to win. It is dishonest and the fact the Obama campaign tried to hide the money it gave to an ACORN partner is suspect.

I am no longer a Democrat because what has happened this year is dishonest and goes against everything a Democrat would be for. Voter suppression, Voter Fraud and Registration fraud are serious issues that undermine our electoral process.

Obviously Mickey Mouse cannot vote - unless some poor guy was actually named that by his parents.

The bottom line, here, folks is that BOTH parties are to blame. Nowhere in this article did it state that ACORN is deliberately, fraudulently registering more Democrats than Republicans.

And I definitely agree with Non-Shouting Laura who pointed out the points that others missed. Add mine to the list. :)

Anonymous -- I don't think it's a good idea to test this out by having your 16-year-old son attempt to vote, particularly by absentee ballot. A spurious voter registration is like vandalism or a prank phone call, while actually voting that way is fraud.

To the other Anonymous who claims to have left the Democratic party over this, please. Are you going to register as a Republican and then leave them over the much more substantive issue of real vote fraud -- Diebold, a *very* Republican-friendly company, still refuses to produce independently verifiable records.

You have got to be kidding if you think you can defend ACORN using any reasoning, or more likely lack there of! The Progressive/Eugenist movement is pathetic and deserves nothing more than what the founders did with Tar and feathers to loyalist, or what the country experienced with McCarthyism in the early 20th century when the progressive movement began.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

More information about formatting options

Progress Illinois' intention is to foster community and to maintain a comfortable and constructive blogging environment. While we encourage and appreciates different points of view, we do not consider it our duty to give a voice to anybody with an opinion.

Discussion on this site is moderated. All comments submitted will be automatically held for review by the editors before posting. Your comment will not appear on the site until it has been approved.

We will not publish comments that we consider:

  • off-topic
  • long-winded or containing excessive text from another source
  • inflammatory
  • commercial promotion

Please leave a name or nickname when commenting, as it makes it easier for others to respond directly.