Explore our content

All types | All dates | All authors
IL Supreme Court
Quick Hit
by Adam Doster
4:21pm
Mon Nov 1, 2010

Choosing Judges

Picking a governor and a set of lawmakers to represent us in the halls of Congress and the statehouse is the primary responsibility of voters on Election Day, but it's not the only choice we face. We've already run through the basics of a gubernatorial recall amendment, which may itself be unconstitutional. Citizens will also decide to elect (or retain) dozens of judges.

If you need help figuring out who is worthy of your support in Cook County, you'd be wise to check out Vote For Judges, a web project created by the Chicago Appleseed Fund for Justice that aggregates scorecards put out by various bar associations and the city's two major newspapers. The Chicago Reporter's Megan Cottrell highlights a few of the legal officials who don't have solid reputations across the region. (So did WBEZ' Sam Hudzik.) One looks especially problematic for progressive voters:

Susan J. McDunn - According to the Tribune, McDunn tried to sidetrack two adoptions by lesbian parents, using her personal beliefs as guidance, rather than the law. The Chicago Council of Lawyers says, "Many lawyers believe she has difficulty handling complex matters that come before her and that she demonstrates an inappropriate temperament." Again, all five groups did not recommend her.

The season's most intense retention battle is taking place just south of Chicago in Illinois' Third Supreme Court District, where Supreme Court Justice Thomas Kilbride is fighting to keep his job. (We've previously written about the race here.) The Democrat has raised roughly $2.5 million in his bid, decidedly more than his major opponents. The outcome of the race will have an impact statewide, potentially during next year's redistricting process. Currently, Kilbride's party holds a 4-3 advantage on the court.

Quick Hit
by Adam Doster
10:08am
Fri Oct 15, 2010

IFT Goes In Big For Judge Kilbride

Illinois Supreme Court Justice Thomas Kilbride, fighting to retain his seat in Illinois' Third District, just got a big boost. The Illinois Federation of Teachers dropped $100,000 into his warchest, according to a disclosure form filed early this morning. This comes one day after JUSTPAC, the political action committee leading the charge to defeat Kilbride, received a contribution of equal value from the American Justice Partnership, an offshoot of the National Association of Manufacturers. Last week, the judge also nabbed $20,000 from the Illinois Pipefitters union and an endorsement from the Tribune

Kilbride will take over as the state's Chief Justice in just about two weeks but needs 60 percent of the vote on November 2 to keep his job. Below is his latest ad, which touts his record on victim's rights:

We profiled this race, and the fraught politics of state judicial elections, here. The State Journal-Register, meanwhile, thinks the wrath the judge has received should serve as a cautionary tale for proponents of the state's gubernatorial recall amendment.

UPDATE (1:45 p.m.): The Illinois Campaign for Political Reform dug through some campaign finance disclosure reports from earlier in the year and found that the teachers union had previously donated $250,000 to Kilbride's campaign. This new contribution brings the total to $350,000 on the year.