Explore our content

All types | All dates | All authors
Wages
Quick Hit
by Robert Dietz
1:11pm
Thu Mar 17, 2011

Daley's Selective Memory On Walmart

Chicago Mayor Richard Daley was in rare form yesterday in announcing the opening of more Walmarts in the city. His speech felt more like a camapign rally or even church sermon than a ribbon-cutting ceremony. He told a gathering in the South Side neighborhood of Englewood that two more stores would create 1,000 jobs. Recalling the fierce six-year battle over Walmarts with organized labor in Chicago, Daley said, "When it comes to people who need a job, don't wait for six years anymore."

If only it were that simple. The mayor is correct, in theory, that building Walmarts on the South Side will bring jobs, though the net gain or loss needs to be tracked carefully; a study last year found Walmart's presence on the West Side caused other outlets to shutter and lay off their employees. But the Walmart fight wasn't about blocking jobs (an argument Daley made yesterday while invoking race) -- it was about livable wages and decent working conditions. It was about demanding more from a massive multinational that hasn't treated its employees well. The fight was about avoiding what community organizers called a "race to the bottom" and demanding city government stand with everyday working people. "It's the role of government to ensure its citizens that you should not have to work a 40-hour week and still be living in poverty and then have to rely on the government for food stamps and Medicaid," St. Sabina's Rev. Michael Pfleger said of the fight back in 2009.

It was about creating good jobs. But Daley doesn't remember any of that.

Quick Hit
by Adam Doster
1:05pm
Fri Nov 19, 2010

The Salaries Of Our Leaders

In the past, we've poked fun at the Illinois Policy Institute's "Spotlight on Spending" series in which the conservative think tank "highlights wasteful or inefficient programs and spending." This week, the group came out with a new white paper comparing the pay of Illinois' constitutional officers with those in other states. According to their research, Illinois ranks in the top 10 for the salaries it paid out to its governor, lieutenant governor, secretary of state, attorney general, treasurer, and comptroller this year. "Accountability for the state’s budget woes should start at the top," the Institute writes. "Illinois’s executive officers shouldn’t be paid more than the nationwide average salary for each position."

Statewide officials are taking umbrage with the report, claiming the authors didn't factor into the data 12 furlough days each officer was forced to take to cut costs. We'd raise a different critique: While it's bad politics to provide elected officials with extravagant salaries, it's a good thing for state governance if the wage gap between the public and the private sector isn't enormous. Illinois needs well qualified people to work in Springfield. If someone can earn three times as much for a comparable gig in the private sector, the incentives are strong for those folks to leave government as fast as possible. It seems pretty clear, for example, that taxpayers are benefiting from paying Attorney General Lisa Madigan $156,600 annually to fight on behalf of them and not special interests who can offer better benefits.

PI Original
by Adam Doster
12:32pm
Mon Oct 4, 2010

Charting A "New Chicago" In 2011 (VIDEO)

Over the next several months, a city-wide coalition of progressive activists are going to work hard to hold the feet of Chicago's mayoral candidates to the proverbial fire.

Quick Hit
by Michael Vanassche
11:08am
Thu Sep 9, 2010

Quinn Hits Brady On Minimum Wage In New Ad

The Quinn campaign has released a new advertisement criticizing GOP gubernatorial nominee Bill Brady for his stance on the minimum wage. Check out "Learn, Chapter 2" below:

By asking "who is this guy," this ad -- along with Quinn's last spot on Brady's gun positions -- tries to give voters a primer on the state senator, whose record is still not very well known in some portions of the state. We've run our own fact check on the minimum wage debate Quinn references, as well.

Quick Hit
by Adam Doster
11:00am
Thu Sep 2, 2010

An Additional Minimum Wage Fact Check

The AP intervened in the Illinois governor's race yesterday, fact checking Gov. Pat Quinn's heavy criticism of GOP nominee Bill Brady's minimum wage stance. The press service correctly points out that Brady's position has switched as the campaign has progressed; initially, he told the media that he favored lowering Illinois' minimum wage of $8.25 per hour to the federal level of $7.25 per hour, but now he says the state should freeze its minimum wage rate until the lower federal figure "catch[es] up." Reporter Deanna Bellandi then whacks Quinn, who has told voters that Brady wants to cut wages, for "overstat[ing] Brady's past comments."

Although this short piece is helpful for folks just getting acquainted with the debate, we'd have liked to see the AP go even further by questioning Brady's assertion that Illinois' wage rate puts the state at a "competitive disadvantage." The Indiana Business review, studying job growth figures between 2003 and 2005, found that "Illinois' increasing minimum wage rates did not reduce overall employment growth for private employers." This tracks with national research, as well. For more context, check out our minimum wage posts here and here.

Quick Hit
by Adam Doster
10:48am
Tue Aug 3, 2010

DGA Jumps On Brady's Minimum Wage Stance

While GOP gubernatorial candidate Bill Brady backtracked slightly on his support for lowering Illinois' minimum wage by $1-per-hour, he hasn't changed his mind that the state's current wage floor is too high. And that's one position the Democratic Governors Association will make sure voters know about before November. Listen to the group's new radio ad below, which debuts today:

For more on the topic, check out our minimum wage primer here.

Quick Hit
by Josh Kalven
12:13pm
Thu Jul 15, 2010

Finding Housing On The Minimum Wage

We've written about the difficult reach for affordable housing among low-income workers in Illinois.  We've also pointed out repeatedly that, contrary to Republican opinion, the minimum wage in the state isn't overly generous.  Recently, Crain's tied both issues together.

They produced an infographic showing how many hours someone would have to work on the current minimum wage ($8.25) to afford fair market rent in the Chicago area for a studio, one-bedroom, two-bedroom and so on.  The numbers are daunting to say the least. You can find it here.

Quick Hit
by Adam Doster
10:19am
Tue Jul 13, 2010

Conservative Group Complains About "Overpaid" Housekeepers

The Illinois Policy Institute's quest to prove that government employees are overpaid has now reached ridiculous levels. After writing an unscientific white paper last month perpetuating the myth of a "state employee wealth class," the conservative think tank penned a blog post yesterday complaining that two housekeepers employed by the state earn a shockingly high salary of ... $28,154 per year.   The author compared that to the mean salary for a housekeeper in Illinois, which is $21,350 (just a nudge above the federal poverty line).  Last week, the Institute also griped about the modest annual salaries earned by DMV cashiers: $31,266, on average.

If their intention is to stoke outrage about government waste, this might not be the best strategy.

Quick Hit
by Adam Doster
1:38pm
Mon Jul 12, 2010

The Tribune's Minimum Wage Straw Man

Coming to the defense of Sen. Bill Brady, the Tribune editorial board wrote a piece over the weekend arguing that Illinois' minimum wage -- which is currently set $1-per-hour above the national level -- "will keep some people from finding jobs because there will be fewer jobs to find." The argument is pretty flimsy. For starters, the paper doesn't use any local evidence to back up their job-loss claim. Reviewing job growth patterns between 2003 and 2005, Michael F. Thompson of the Indiana Business Review found that "Illinois' increasing minimum wage rates did not reduce overall employment growth for private employers."

Furthermore, they suggest that supporters back a higher minimum wage because it "translates into a more diligent and efficient work force." Progressives don't argue that minimum wage hikes improve the economy by motivating workers. Rather, they contend that putting additional cash into the hands of low-wage workers spurs the economy by boosting demand, a position held by some economic outfit called the Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago.