Explore our content

All types | All dates | All authors
Pensions
Quick Hit
by Adam Doster
12:42pm
Thu Dec 9, 2010

The Problem With State Bankruptcy, Part Two

Earlier this week, we expressed concern that some conservative pundits and policy makers are pushing states facing large budget deficits (both in the short- and long-term) to declare bankruptcy. Reuters' James Pethokoukis provides the latest example about why this approach is problematic.

Republicans in Congress have introduced a bill that suspends the ability of states and localities to sell tax-exempt bonds if they don't report their pension-fund liabilities to the U.S. Treasury Department. (State sovereignty, it seems, is a right conservatives uphold only when it's politically convenient.) The hope among some on the right is that "the shock" of the debt load will, in the words of Pethokoukis, "grease the way towards explicitly permitting states to declare bankruptcy." And that's important because it would give Republican lawmakers an opportunity to smash union contracts. "Allowing them the same ability to renegotiate obligations," he writes, "could enable them to slash public employees’ lavish benefits, a big factor in their financial woes ... From the Republican perspective, the fiscal crisis on the state level provides a golden opportunity to defund a key Democratic interest group."

Never mind that public employee pensions are, by and large, not lavish at all. Never mind that those workers bargained for those retirement benefits with the state. Never mind that the vast majority don't earn Social Security. And never mind that the state has several fiscal options to pay off the obligations, if they can muster the strength to do so. If conservatives can figure out a way to bash organized labor, they always will.

Quick Hit
by Adam Doster
10:33am
Wed Dec 8, 2010

Moody's On Illinois' Pension Problem

Even if Illinois borrows to pay this year's annual pension contribution, the state's bond rating may take another tumble.

That's the word from Moody’s Investors Services, which issued a report Monday warning that selling another $3.75 billion in bonds to cover public employee retirement costs may not prevent another downgrade. (Maintaining a high rating, and proving Illinois is credit worthy, is important because it keeps the state's borrowing costs low.) Lawmakers have already sold $13.5 billion worth of pension-related debt over the last decade, including $3.5 billion last fiscal year.

The alternatives to borrowing are no better though, a point even Moody's concedes. Lawmakers could skip the payment entirely, costing the pension systems roughly $25 billion in future value. They could divert $3.75 billion from the General Revenue Funds, thereby starving cash-strapped agencies like the Department of Human Services. Selling bonds, on the other hand, "would at least limit deterioration in the funded status of the state’s pensions, which are the lowest-funded among state," according to the credit rating agency.

After the State Senate put off the decision for months, passing SB 3514 during the final days of the January veto session is probably the best outcome for which taxpayers can hope.

Quick Hit
by Adam Doster
2:14pm
Fri Dec 3, 2010

Meeks The Conservative

State Sen. James Meeks is quickly becoming the most conservative candidate in Chicago's mayoral race.

The South Side Democrat launched his campaign in mid-November with the assistance of Andy McKenna, the former chairman of the Illinois Republican Party, and the chief lobbyist for the culturally-conservative Catholic Conference of Illinois. Although he did so graciously, Meeks voted against the civil unions bill in Springfield Wednesday, the only black lawmaker in either chamber to do so, which puts him at odds with the Black Caucus. Today, Meeks sent out a press release claiming he's the only mayoral hopeful who has the "conviction and the leadership to solve the [city] pension fund crisis." From the statement:

"All the stakeholders share the same goal, and we will find a solution together. The greatest risk is doing nothing or too little," said Meeks. "I believe that we must: increase employee contributions toward their pensions, move to a two-tiered system that reduces benefit accruals for new employees, and increase the average retirement age. Contributing to the employees pensions funds must also be a higher priority if we are going to head off the failure of the pension funds."

It's no secret that poor budgeting practices and the financial meltdown have severely increased Chicago's unfunded pension liability. Bold action will be needed by city officials in the coming years to get the funds back on firm financial ground. Yet Meeks' initial recommendation -- to reduce benefits and increase the retirement age for new workers -- is frustrating to read. Like state employees, it's not as if city workers make out like bandits once they retire. "Most don't participate in the federal Social Security program, and the vast majority receives modest benefits averaging about $40,000 a year," the Tribune found last month. That's a point that should not be ignored when future negotiations ramp up.

Quick Hit
by Adam Doster
11:58am
Wed Dec 1, 2010

Recapping A Busy Day In The Capitol

Yesterday was a busy day in the state capitol. In a historic vote, the House passed a civil unions bill, which could be signed into law as early as this week. (We covered the debate, in all of its glory, here.) In another hot-button debate, the chamber voted down a medical marijuana pilot program to the dismay of its chief sponsor, State Rep. Lou Lang (D-Skokie).

Those weren't the only bills considered. The House overwhelmingly passed a bill (SB 3538) that lowers retirement benefits for future firefighters and police officers, who were exempt from the "pension reform" legislation approved this past spring. (Because the bill included a steep ramp-up in Chicago's contributions to its pension system, Mayor Richard Daley is furious at its passage.) A bill (SB 3539) to abolish the death penalty cleared committee but was held from full consideration. State Rep. Karen Yarbrough (D-Chicago) says she is one or two votes shy of reaching a majority. (The Sun-Times editorializes in favor of the measure this morning.) And a major gambling expansion (SB 737) squeaked out of a State Senate committee yesterday. The bill, slightly reworked from the original version, would create licenses for five new Illinois casinos, boost the number of slot machines at existing Illinois river boats, and add slots at Illinois racetracks. David Ormsby provides a good overview here.

The action moves to the State Senate this morning. We will provide updates about their progress today and tomorrow.

PI Original
by Adam Doster
1:35pm
Mon Nov 29, 2010

Civil Unions Tops Veto Session Agenda

When the General Assembly reconvenes this week to finish up its annual business, there could be action taken on several high-profile bills.

PI Original
by Adam Doster
2:32pm
Thu Nov 18, 2010

Signs Of Progress In Springfield

During the first three days of Illinois' fall veto session, the wheels started to turn on a few initiatives that are critically important to the moral and economic health of the state.