Explore our content

All types | All dates | All authors
Media
Quick Hit
by Adam Doster
9:06am
Mon Apr 26, 2010

Greising Ignores Legal Dispute Over Pensions

Joshua Rauh, a finance professor at Northwestern University, is not a fan of the pension reform measure the General Assembly passed in March. "It was like praising a doctor who has been watching a patient bleed to death and then orders a band-aid," he wrote at his school's finance blog on April 15. To erase the state's pension debt overhang, Rauh thinks deeper cuts are in order. That means altering the pension benefit packages of current employees, a move he tells the Chicago News-Cooperative's David Greising is "legal."  What Greising fails to tell readers, however, is that the legality is very much in dispute.

Indeed, former Illinois Appellate Court judge Gino DiVito distributed a legal memo on April 13 arguing the language in the Illinois Constitution protecting current employee pensions is "crystal clear." In an April 9 Tribune op-ed, former judge and congressman Abner Mikva came to the same conclusion.

It's not clear why Greising ignored these arguments. Any fair piece wouldn't omit them entirely.

Quick Hit
by Josh Kalven
11:40am
Sat Apr 24, 2010

A Nail In A Campaign?

The headline on today's Tribune story about Alexi Giannoulias and Broadway Bank is a strange one: "Bank failure a nail in Giannoulias campaign."  So are they likening his campaign to a coffin? Seriously?  Ellen Beth Gill Carl Nyberg noticed it as well:

If the Trib isn't referring to the idiom "a nail in the coffin" then perhaps they can explain how referring to a nail in the campaign makes sense. Normally when a carpenter puts a nail in a roof or some other project it represents forward progress, right?

By the way, for all its attention on Broadway Bank, the Tribune still hasn't reported on Mark Kirk's health care "repeal" flip-flop.

Quick Hit
by Josh Kalven
9:08am
Thu Apr 22, 2010

MSNBC Covers "Save Our State" Rally

In her segment last night on the national discussion regarding the value of government, MSNBC's Rachel Maddow highlighted yesterday's budget rally in Springfield.  She noted that the crowd had at one point chanted "Show some guts!" (watch a clip of that chant here) and went on to discuss the issue with Pennsylvania Gov. Ed Rendell (full video on the MSNBC site):

During the interview portion, Rendell went on to say: "I think there are progressives in this country who are way out in front of the politicians, and I love the fact that the Illinois protesters were saying, 'Show some guts,' because I think that's exactly what we need to do. If we're gonna go down in November -- and I don't think we are -- if we're gonna go down, let's go down fighting for the things we believe in. Let's not be afraid."

Quick Hit
by Josh Kalven
1:06pm
Wed Apr 21, 2010

Not Quite ...

NBC 5's Edward McClellan on the "Save Our State" rally today:

The Responsible Budget Coalition, the organizers of the “Save Our State” rally, believes that Gov. Pat Quinn’s one-point income tax is the only alternative to unacceptable cuts in education.

In fact, the RBC membership has expressed great disappointment with Quinn's proposed one-point income tax hike.  Following the governor's March 10 budget address, the coalition said his proposal "falls far short of the comprehensive tax reform that's needed."  Shriver Center President John Bouman -- whom McClellan quotes in his piece -- had this to say: "A temporary band-aid isn't going to get us through this crisis or pay our unpaid bills."  And SEIU Healthcare IL/IN President Keith Kelleher responded: "[W]e need more than a 1% increase to pull Illinois out of this budget crisis." (Full disclosure: SEIU Illinois sponsors this website.)

The RBC is flooding the statehouse today in support of House Bill 174, which would raise the income tax rate by two percentage points and passed the Illinois Senate last May.

Quick Hit
by Josh Kalven
9:49am
Tue Apr 20, 2010

Living Wage Ordinance Gets Short Shrift On WTTW

Last Friday, Chicago Tonight's "Week In Review" show kicked off with a discussion of the ongoing Wal-Mart debate at City Hall.  Watch it:

Unfortunately this discussion missed an important new component of the debate: the ordinance championed by the Good Jobs Chicago coalition and introduced Wednesday by Ald. Freddrenna Lyle (6th Ward).  Unlike previous attempts to address Wal-Mart's race-to-the-bottom wages, this measure doesn't direcly target the mega-retailer or big-box stores in general.  Rather, it's living wage requirements apply to companies with a payroll exceeding 50 people that "receive financial assistance" from the city -- such as tax increment financing (TIF) subsidies.   The ordinance represents an opportunity to have a broader discussion about what the city's residents are willing to demand in return for all the tax dollars we send back to local companies.  But that conversation can't happen if outlets like WTTW ignore it.

Quick Hit
by Josh Kalven
4:41pm
Mon Apr 12, 2010

Best Of Luck, Angela!

We've got some bittersweet news to report today: Angela Caputo, who has written for PI since September 2008, is moving to the Chicago Reporter, where she'll be specializing in investigative journalism.  We've been privileged to have her on staff for the past 19 months, during which she has done great reporting on all manner of topics, showing a particularly keen eye for stories about Chicago city politics.  She'll be missed and we wish her the best in her new post.

Quick Hit
by Adam Doster
10:42am
Mon Apr 5, 2010

Kiddie Gloves For Kirk

The Tribune was quick to highlight Republican Mark Kirk's initial broadside against the recently-passed health care bill, in which he pledged to "repeal" the package if elected to the U.S. Senate.  Yet in the weeks since, as Rich Miller noted, Illinois' largest paper has not printed one follow-up piece noting that Kirk has backed away from that pledge -- this despite the fact that the story has received national attention.

Chalk it up as just another example of the kind of softball coverage Kirk gets in this town.

Quick Hit
by Adam Doster
11:48am
Tue Mar 30, 2010

A School Funding Primer

Last month, the Tribune's Bob Secter wrote a helpful piece laying out the basic facts about Illinois' gigantic budget deficit. Today, he delivers again, providing a solid overview of the unsustainable and unequal manner in which the state funds K-12 education.

The basic facts, which we've written about plenty, are pretty simple. The state legislature has never provided enough funding for education, a problem that's gotten worse this decade. In 2008, the state's share of school funding dropped to 27.5 percent, down from 33 percent 18 years prior. That's shifted the burden onto localities, who solicit property taxes to pay for books, teachers, and other essentials. But all property tax bills aren't created equal. Rich districts with huge houses and thriving businesses can raise more money through property taxes while keeping the tax rate in those districts modest. Poor districts with low property values need to charge much higher rates if they have any hope of keeping pace. "Per-pupil spending tends to follow the old real estate maxim," writes Secter, "location, location, location."

Illinois' funding structure will continue to haunt the state unless changes are made. HB 174, which passed the Senate and which Secter references only in passing, would double the property tax credit and funnel extra revenue generated from an income tax hike towards schools, at least once the state's backlog of bills is paid off. It's a workable solution to the funding crisis and one key aspect of the tax reform debate that's too often ignored, even by proponents.